Why the most important investment in your shop might have nothing to do with marketing
I’ve spent over 15 years in the automotive aftermarket and have had the opportunity to visit more than 2,000 repair shops throughout the U.S and in Canada. I’ve met some incredible shop owners, talented technicians, and service advisors who genuinely care about the people they serve.
But there’s something I’ve noticed over the years that I believe deserves more attention. We spend so much time worrying about the competition down the street that we sometimes overlook the competition happening inside our own four walls.

And sometimes, our biggest competitor is ourselves. Think about it.
How often do we hear shop owners talk about needing more cars? More leads? More phone calls? More marketing? The natural reaction is to increase the ads budget or launch another email or text campaign.
There’s nothing wrong with any of that. I’m a marketing guy and I’ll be the first to say that marketing is important. We need more marketing! But here’s my question: What happens after the marketing works?
What happens when that customer calls or schedules the appointment and walks through your door?
Are You Building Relationships or Processing Transactions?
Imagine walking into a restaurant where nobody acknowledges you. You place your order, hand over your money, and eventually hear a staff member shout, “Number 27! Your order is ready!”
Now imagine walking into another restaurant where someone greets you by name, remembers what you ordered last time, asks how your family is doing, and genuinely seems happy to see you.
Same basic transaction. Completely different experience, right? Which business would you rather return to? Our industry is no different.
Your customers aren’t repair orders. They’re not invoice numbers. They’re not the 8:30 a.m. appointment or the silver Honda sitting in bay three. They’re people. And people want to feel like people.
I just returned from Arizona, where I was visiting an independent repair shop. I won’t mention the shop’s name, but I witnessed an interaction between a service advisor and a first-time customer that really stuck with me.
After the interaction, I walked over to the advisor and asked a simple question. “What did you learn about that new customer?” (I overheard the customer say it was his first visit.)
The advisor thought for a moment and responded, “Well, they have another car. It’s a Tesla.” My response? “What else?” Silence. That was it.
Now, I’m not sharing this to criticize the advisor. I actually used it as an opportunity to coach them on something I believe is incredibly important: We need to stop focusing solely on the vehicle and start getting to know the person who owns it.
Do you know their first name? Where they’re from? Whether they own a business? Whether they have children? What they do for a living?
I’m not suggesting we interrogate customers. Genuine relationships develop through natural conversation, curiosity, and actually listening.
Maybe they’re a small-business owner trying to keep their delivery vehicle on the road. Maybe they’re a parent whose daughter just got her first car. Maybe they’re retired and planning a cross-country road trip. Those details really do matter.
Not because you’re trying to sell them something, but because you’re taking a genuine interest in someone who has chosen to trust you. Out of all of the places they could have picked, they decided to pick YOU. Seriously, search for any type of business on Google, auto repair included.
If you’re not satisfied with the initial results and sponsored ads, all you have to do is select “More Businesses” and watch what happens. It will collapse dozens of other options.
As a shop owner, you don’t have the same luxury as the consumer. Every new phone call and every new appointment is a golden opportunity to win a customer for life! We have one “at bat” and the chance to hit a home run.
You May Never Get a Second Chance
We’ve all heard the expression: You never get a second chance to make a first impression.
According to a 2023 national consumer survey by TCN, a cloud-based call center software company, 73% of Americans say they’re likely to abandon a brand after just one poor customer service experience. Think about that.
You could spend thousands of dollars attracting someone to your shop, only to lose the opportunity for a lifelong relationship because of one disappointing interaction.
And here’s the unfortunate part: Many of those customers won’t tell you why they never came back.
Ever go to a restaurant and you didn’t like the food? What happens when the server comes over and says, “How is everything?” Eight out of 10 of us will say “Everything is fine.” Why?
Because we don’t want to engage in that discussion in that environment or make them feel bad. We just know we’ll never go back. That’s how many of our customers think.
They’ll quietly leave, won’t write a review, and just start using the shop down the street.
Your Service Advisors Are Relationship Builders
I’ve always believed service advisors have one of the most important roles in the entire business. They’re not simply there to answer phones, write estimates, or collect payments.
They’re consultants. Educators. Problem-solvers. And, in most cases, the face of your business. A great service advisor doesn’t just tell a customer they need brakes.
They explain what the technician found, why the repair matters, what could happen if it’s postponed, and how it fits into the customer’s priorities and budget.
They ask questions. They listen. They educate. And most importantly, they help customers make informed decisions without feeling pressured.
That’s the difference between selling a repair and earning someone’s trust.
Before You Increase Your Ad Spend, Invest in Your People
Here’s a challenge I’d give every shop owner reading this. Before you increase your advertising budget, ask yourself how much time you’re investing in developing your service advisors.
Not once a quarter. Not during an annual training event. Every single day.
Practice the greeting. Practice answering the phone. Practice asking better questions. Practice explaining recommended service. Practice handling objections without becoming defensive.
Role-play real customer situations. Review conversations. Celebrate great interactions. Coach the moments that could have gone better.
Do it so consistently that delivering an exceptional customer experience becomes second nature.
It shouldn’t feel scripted. The entire purpose of training is to make the process so natural that your advisors can focus on the person standing in front of them. And don’t confuse friendliness with relationship building.
A smile and a friendly greeting are a great start. But remembering that a customer’s son just left for college, asking how their new business is going, or following up after a major repair?
That’s something entirely different. That’s being human.
The Customer Isn’t the Transaction. The Customer Is the Relationship.
I’m not suggesting we stop investing in marketing. Quite the opposite. Great marketing and great customer experiences should work together.
Marketing earns the opportunity to start a relationship. Your team at the front counter determines whether that relationship continues.
And when you earn someone’s trust, you aren’t just earning their next oil change. You’re earning the opportunity to serve them for years, potentially across multiple vehicles and even generations of their family.
So the next time you’re wondering how to compete with the shop down the street, consider looking inward first. Ask yourself whether your customers feel known, appreciated, educated, and genuinely cared for.
Because the most successful shops won’t necessarily be the ones spending the most money to attract customers. They’ll be the ones giving customers every reason to never want to leave.
Stop thinking about the next transaction. Start thinking about the relationship for life.
Mike DelaCruz is the Founder and CEO of Overdryve, a marketing management and technology company serving the automotive aftermarket. With over 15 years of industry experience and firsthand experience visiting nearly 2,000 automotive repair shops nationwide, DelaCruz has built his career helping independent repair businesses grow through smarter marketing, stronger customer relationships, and technology. A national speaker and automotive industry advocate, he is also leading the development of Overdryve CRM+ Marketing Intelligence, an AI-powered platform designed to help repair shops attract new customers, improve retention, and make more informed business decisions.
Email DelaCruz at mike@overdryveinc.com or phone at 510-861-0132.



Comments are closed.