Most fleet leads go nowhere because the shop is talking to the wrong person. Here’s how one shop learned to find the one who decides where the vans get serviced.
Every shop owner I know has driven past a lot full of work vans and thought, “We should be fixing those.” I’ve thought it plenty of times.
The hard part isn’t spotting the vehicles. It’s figuring out who at that company actually decides where they get serviced, and then getting in front of that person in a way that doesn’t feel like a cold sales pitch.
At Super Eagle Auto Care, our nine-bay shop in Charlotte, N.C., we went from two or three fleet accounts to more than 40. A lot of what changed wasn’t our price or our service. It was that we stopped pitching whoever answered the phone and started finding the person who owns the maintenance decision.
Here’s what I’ve learned about that, for shop owners who already have a solid retail business and want steadier work.
The driver is not the decision maker (but they know who is)
The first mistake I made was assuming the person driving the truck had a say. Sometimes they do. Most of the time, the driver takes the vehicle where they’re told. If you win over a driver, you’ve made a friend, which is worth something, but you haven’t won an account.
What the driver does have is information. They know who they call when the check engine light comes on. They know whether there’s a “guy” in the office who handles it, whether the company uses a fleet card or a fleet management company, and whether anybody is happy with the current shop.
When a fleet vehicle comes in on a one-off visit, or you strike up a conversation at a parts counter or a gas station, ask one simple question: “Who do you call when this thing needs work?” That name is the lead. The truck isn’t.
The phone works the same way. On a prospecting day I make about 20 cold calls, and in my experience it takes roughly a hundred calls to land one account. Almost every one of those calls starts with a gatekeeper, usually a receptionist.
I don’t pitch the receptionist. I ask a question that points me to the person who decides, and most of the time that’s the manager or the general manager. The receptionist isn’t there to buy anything, but they’re usually glad to tell you who handles the vehicles.
Titles lie, so map the company instead
At a big national company, there may be a person with “Fleet Manager” on their business card. At the local businesses that make up most of the fleet work an independent shop can win, that title often doesn’t exist. The maintenance decision might sit with:
- The owner, at smaller service companies
- An operations manager or general manager
- An office manager who also handles the vehicles
- A branch or district manager, if it’s one location of a larger company
- A fleet coordinator who schedules service but needs sign-off from someone above them
So instead of searching for a title, I try to answer three questions about each company:
- Who schedules service? This is the person who feels the pain when a vehicle is down.
- Who approves the spending? Sometimes it’s the same person. Often it isn’t.
- Who can say “Go try that shop”? This is the one you need to reach.
On a company with more than a handful of vehicles, those can be three different people. Getting to all of them is why fleet prospecting takes more patience than retail marketing.
One telecom company we work with, with more than 100 vehicles, took more than 30 outreach attempts before they sent us a car. That included phone calls, in-person drop-ins with doughnuts and mailers. Part of the reason it took that long was that we were learning who did what inside the company.
Know whether a fleet management company is in the picture
Before you put much time into a lead, find out whether the company runs its vehicles through a fleet management company such as Enterprise, Holman, Wheels or Element, or a platform like Fleetio. It changes the conversation.
If they do, the local manager often still has a say in which shop the vehicles go to, but the shop needs to be set up to bill the way that program wants. We bill however the customer wants, and we use AutoIntegrate, which connects us to Enterprise, Fleetio, Wheels, Element and others.
Being able to say “We already work with your program” takes a real objection off the table before the decision maker has to raise it.
If they don’t use one, you’re usually dealing directly with the person who pays the bills, and things like invoicing, payment terms and how you send approvals matter more.
Either way, knowing this before your first real conversation tells the decision maker you’ve done your homework.
Getting in front of the right person
Once you know who you’re after, the goal is to be useful and visible, not to close a deal on the first call. A few things that have worked for us:
Show up in person, with something small
Doughnuts can help you get past the front desk and give you a reason to ask, politely, who handles vehicle maintenance. You aren’t asking for a meeting. You’re asking for a name and leaving a card.
Make the follow-up about their problem, not your shop
Fleet managers don’t care about your bay count. They care about how long their vehicles are off the road and whether they’ll get a straight answer on cost. On our fleet page we lead with same-day service, a vehicle health report every visit, complimentary Uber or loaner, and easy drop-off and pick-up, because those answer the questions a fleet decision maker is actually asking.
Ask questions you already know the answers to
When I finally get the general manager on the line, I don’t open with what we do. I ask about what they need: how fast they need vehicles turned around, whether quick oil changes matter, how much downtime hurts them.
I usually know the answers before I ask, because every fleet needs its vehicles back on the road. But when the manager says it out loud, the conversation becomes about their needs, and if we can meet them, we get the business.
Use more than one channel
Calls, emails, drop-ins and mailers all reach people differently. Some decision makers never answer an unknown number but will read a postcard. Others will only talk to you if you’ve stopped by in person.
Ask for one vehicle, not the whole fleet
Nobody hands over 50 trucks to a shop they’ve never used. But a lot of managers will try one. With that telecom account, we serviced one car first. After that, I got a text and they sent us five at once.
Keep track of every person, not just every company
Here’s where most shops quietly lose fleet leads: the follow-up falls apart. When you’re working a company where the scheduler, the approver and the owner are three different people, you have to remember who you talked to, what they said and when to circle back. Multiply that by dozens of companies and a notepad stops working.
I work more than 200 fleet contacts a month, and that’s only manageable because everything is in one place. I use a CRM to keep those multi-contact follow-ups straight. Whatever you use, even a spreadsheet, the rule is the same: record the person, their role in the decision, the last touch and the next step. If you can’t see that at a glance, leads will slip.
Timing matters more than the pitch
The honest truth about fleet decision makers is that most of them already have a shop. They aren’t looking for you, and they won’t switch because you sent a nice email. They switch when something goes wrong: the current shop is backed up, a vehicle sits for a week, an invoice surprises them or the shop they used closes.
You can’t control when that happens. What you can control is whether you’re the name they think of when it does. That’s why the 30-plus touches on that telecom account weren’t wasted. Once they needed us, we were there.
Then keep the promise
Finding the decision maker gets you the first car. Keeping the account is about what happens next: the vehicle comes back when you said it would, the invoice matches the approval and the manager never has to chase you for an update.
The person who decided to give you a try put their name on that choice inside their company. Make them look good, and the next five vehicles tend to follow.
As I tell anyone who asks how we grew our fleet work: it’s all about building relationships with the fleet manager and delivering on your promise. The first part starts with knowing who that manager really is.
Nathan Wade is Fleet Manager at Super Eagle Auto Care, a nine-bay independent shop in Charlotte, N.C., that services more than 40 fleet accounts. He is also the founder of Fleet Searcher, a CRM that helps independent repair shops find and follow up with fleet customers.







Comments are closed.